Pages

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

In Defense of My House




As a follow-up to Allie's post about Hufflepuff, I would like to give you my thoughts on Slytherin. Maybe it will help people understand why I am proud to be a member of the "evil" house.


The following is an excerpt from "The Better Side of Slytherin" which is an original editorial by Black Lily. You can read the whole thing at this link (I recommend you do, it proves a lot of points I've been trying to convince people of!)


"People have pointed out before to me that the Sorting Hat said to unite together, and that Slytherins are the people least likely to do this. The most obvious piece of evidence is that there were no Slytherins in the DA. But think about it-- did any Slytherins even KNOW about the DA? Hermione told the people that she knew about her plan to have Harry teach, but she doesn't hang out with Slytherins. And even if any of them had shown up, would they have been allowed in? Gryffindor house in particular seems to be biased against the Slytherins. Perhaps if someone reached out to the Slytherins in the background, the ones who don't make enemies for themselves, we would have far more unity within the school.


There is one last point to make to show more of the good qualities of Slytherin House. If I remember correctly, Slytherin had won the House Cup several years running before Harry and Draco arrived at the school. House Points are given for good behavior and knowledge, and taken away for bad behavior and rule-breaking. Slytherins, on the whole, can't be that bad to have won the cup so many times. Perhaps it's only a question of knowing when to keep their mouths shut, and not doing anything in front of a teacher, but that takes intelligence and skill, even if it's not the best thing to do."


I hope this has helped changed your minds about Slytherins...but somehow I doubt it :)

5 comments:

  1. Very good arguements! But I don't know if Alex will be convinced... :)

    But about the house cup, doesn't Snape favor the Slytherins a little? He takes points away from Gryffindor when Hermione doesn't raise her hand, but he never really takes points from Slytherin...?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I respect Slytherin. They are not all bad!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Another point- Hagrid says no wizard that ever went bad was not in Slytherin. But he thought Sirius had gone bad....
    Peter Pettigrew went bad and was not in Slytherin!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yayyy guys!!!! And yes Alex will definitely not be convinced...the last sentence was mostly aimed at her :)
    WELLLL all right Snape does favor the Slytherins. BUT lots of the other teachers favor Harry. McGonagall gave him a broom, Snape is pretty much the only teacher who gives him detention, he's Dumbledore's favorite student...so really it all evens out in my opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Speaking of Slytherin, have you seen this interview with Tom Felton?
    http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1662737/tom-felton-harry-potter.jhtml

    ReplyDelete